There was so much goodness in the box I think I have missed the "official" response form so, here is a review....

Mulled wine mallow - surprised my in it's flavour and the memories of Christmas past that it evoked. Very good thank you
Snowball Fudge - For me a total win - loved it, The combination of mallow with the fudge cannot be easy to achieve but was bang on for the season in my opinion
Reindeer Poo - as a fan of your eponymous puffin poo I kept this until last and, it did not disappoint. Definitely one to include IMHO
Rummy raisin tablet - anything with your tablet works I reckon and this can do no wrong. However, I think you are missing a flavour trick but, more on that at the end...
Cranberry and apple mallow - this did not work for me, but did for my partner. I think it was the apple flavour; if it had been apple and cinnamon with cranberry then maybe?
Turkish delight fudge - almost bang on but, please lose the rose petals which seemed like "odd bits of cardboard" in the mouth - we buy Turkish delight every Christmas and now we will have to find this fudge also. How about a creme de menthe version? (Just because we buy that with Turkish delight :))
Almond tablet - very good but a hint of something to suggest "mince pie with an almond frangipane" might take it to another level?
Christmas pudding fudge - when does it go on sale please?
Bucks Fizz mallow - this one did not work for me; I think I hoped for more of the orange flavour I associate with the drink....?
Gingerbread mallow - loved this one, along with peanut butter, I think ginger is one of my "go to" flavours"

And so to the one I think is missing. Last Christmas we bought Nicola's Whisky Marmalade and, it was absolutely awesome! We made it last as long as possible and have been looking for a new batch to be sold but, not seen it ... yet. Now, this flavour would work with tablet or fudge - and possibly even mallow and, to our taste, would be a total Christmas winner!

Hope this review helps. Thank you for the great products you produce up there in Shetland and for making them available to us across the UK!

Love this tablet, it has the most wonderful creamy taste, the only problem is not eating it all in one go

Too sweet for me I'm afraid but good service and nicely presented.

Very good chocolate which you can’t stop nibbling at, don’t care what they were called but they are oh so good.

Nice texture and festive smell

My daughter and I tried some of each of these new flavours of fudge, tablet and mallow. Although we didn’t like some and loved others, it was so much fun! Such a good idea and great value too

Another great mallow from Island larder

Very tasty treats. Shame the pouch wasn't a bit bigger as I want to share them with my dart ladies and I will have to cut them smaller.

I love it

Delicious and fun, and a lovely way to celebrate one of the islands’ most charismatic seabirds.

Although I haven’t tasted these yet as I’ve put them away to go into Xmas stockings! The idea is brilliant!

All of the yummy goodness in my Christmas box, the mulled wine & gingerbread mallows were lovely, not much taste in the cranberry and apple mallow. The snowball fudge was amazing as was reindeer poo. Loved the tablet. Well done guys.

All of the beautiful goodies were so tasty but the Christmas pudding fudge, rummy raison tablet and snow ball fudge were insanely scrumptious!

A total success! Finally decided on a favourite item, the Buck’s Fizz Mallow. Everything else was absolutely amazing.

Thank you for supplying such wonderful sweet treats as Puffin Poo, Shetland Pony Poo and Vanilla/Tablet Mallow. The little pieces were sugary heaven and a lot of self control is needed not to eat the lot. Definitely a winner winner puffin poo for dinner.